Deconstruct false narrative of China created by West

Illustration: Liu Xidan/GT

Illustration: Liu Rui/GT

This summer, I embarked on a journey to Baoji, a city in Northwest China's Shaanxi Province steeped in China's ancient history.

Like countless other visitors, my primary destination was the Baoji Bronze Ware Museum, home to a treasure trove of artifacts from China's Bronze Age.

One artifact stood out above all others: the He Zun, a bronze wine vessel that holds immense historical and linguistic significance.

The He Zun, dating back to the early Western Zhou Dynasty (circa 1046BC-771BC), bears the earliest known inscription of zhongguo, the two Chinese characters for the English word "China." The phrase zhaizizhongguo, meaning "dwelling in this central land," is etched into its surface, a testament to the longevity of Chinese civilization.

When a Westerner who has never been to China thinks of China, what's the first thing that comes to mind? Maybe, an ancient Eastern nation known for its porcelain, a powerful entity regarded by the US as a rival or even an enemy, or a nation led by a communist party that differs from Western civilization and ideology. If this is what they think of first, they are clearly unaware of the meaning behind zhongguoand what it represents.

In the ancient context from He Zun, "China" referred not to a nation-state as we understand it today, but to a central geographical area. Specifically, it indicated the region surrounding present-day Luoyang in Henan Province, which was considered the heart of the Zhou polity. This nuance is crucial for understanding the evolution of Chinese identity over millennia.

It's important to emphasize that this early usage primarily denotes a geographical concept rather than a national or ethnic one. The focus was on determining the location for the central seat of government, not on defining a nation in the modern sense. 

This stands in stark contrast to the formation of European states, which often coalesced around ethnic and linguistic groups, frequently intertwined with religious identities. These divergent origins have profoundly influenced how these civilizations conceptualize statehood and nationhood to this day.

The notion of China as the "Middle Kingdom" has long held sway in Western understanding, often oversimplifying China's complex historical self-perception. 

This oversimplification has inadvertently created a linguistic trap, suggesting that China's very emergence was driven by an inherent, imperialistic desire to unify tianxia, or "all under heaven," a concept that has been frequently misinterpreted in Western discourse.

My colleague, Wang Wen, Executive Dean of the Chongyang Institute for Financial Studies at Renmin University of China, provides valuable insight into this issue. In his thought-provoking article "Is the name 'China' full of imperialist overtones?" Wang traces the roots of this misunderstanding. He argues that since the publication of Samuel Wells Williams' influential book The Middle Kingdom in 1883, the global understanding of China has been heavily influenced by Western academia's narrative of "China equals the Middle Kingdom," portraying it as a nationalistic empire. 

Wang contends that it is problematic to perpetuate this historical interpretation in analyzing China's contemporary rise. It risks fabricating a false narrative of China seeking to unify the world under its rule, inadvertently lending credence to alarmist theories of a "China threat" or "Chinese hegemony." 

Such misinterpretations can have serious implications for international relations and global stability.

Understanding China through the origin of its name is not merely an academic exercise; it's crucial for accurately conveying China's story to the world. The narrative surrounding the etymology of zhongguoreflects a critical choice: should we reexamine China from the roots of its civilization, or continue to operate within the traditional Western cognitive framework?

At its core, this is a question of how to deconstruct outdated perceptions and establish more accurate ones. This process of reevaluation directly impacts our ability to comprehensively and accurately understand Chinese modernization, a concept that has a long historical and cultural background which has gained prominence in recent years.

The author is a senior editor with the People's Daily, and currently a senior fellow with the Chongyang Institute for Financial Studies at the Renmin University of China. [email protected]. Follow him on X @dinggangchina

版权声明:本文内容由互联网用户自发贡献,该文观点仅代表作者本人。本站仅提供信息存储空间服务,不拥有所有权,不承担相关法律责任。如发现本站有涉嫌抄袭侵权/违法违规的内容, 请发送邮件至 [email protected] 举报,一经查实,本站将立刻删除。

(5)
打赏 微信扫一扫 微信扫一扫 支付宝扫一扫 支付宝扫一扫
上一篇2024-10-23 07:36
下一篇 2024-10-23 08:07

相关推荐

  • 新济公活佛无限钻石版下载

    新济公活佛内购破解版是一款由南京丰投信息科技有限公司精心打造的神话题材卡牌手游。游戏打破传统对战的模式,采用策略布阵任意滑动操控角色,演绎指尖的华丽盛宴。在这里你还可以享受即时战斗玩法带来的快感哦!那 …

    2024-10-23
    1228865263
  • 怀孕之后,这几个“危险区”,孕妈请谨慎!

    作为新手孕妈,一定会有对孕期里的小知识难免忽略,没有过来人的指点迷津,自然就会是一头雾水,可是怀孕可是人命关天的大事容不得半点马虎劲,对于孕期里的危险事,请孕妈们一定做提个心眼,谨慎行事为妙。下面我带 …

    2024-10-23
    79186798
  • 央视揭0元培训课诈骗套路,究竟是什么

    “0元学”听起来似乎是一个极具吸引力的机会,让很多人产生了“不花一分钱就能学到知识”的错觉。然而,这些培训机构往往会通过夸大宣传、虚假承诺等手段来吸引消费者。他们声称可以提供短期速成、财富增值等效果, …

    2024-10-23
    116792
  • 史诗级任务《新天骄》魔星天劫引出开年大戏

    享受了春节这个长长的慵懒的假期,在回归工作的时候,“收心”一定是大多数玩家面对的第一困难,《新天骄》特别准备了史诗级的任务来帮助玩家调整状态。玩家的任务是:斩妖屠魔。维护世界和 …

    2024-10-23
    896
  • 熊大叔餐厅破解版下载

    熊大叔餐厅无限点卷金币版是熊大叔为儿童打造的专属厨房模拟游戏,该游戏画面非常可爱卡通化,游戏玩法非常简单,操作流畅,就算是小朋友也能自己操作,还能培养动手能力!喜欢的朋友们,欢迎大家来2265安卓网下 …

    2024-10-23
    623218
  • 孩子做错事不认错怎么办

    在家庭教育中,当孩子犯错而不愿认错时,很多父母会感到无奈和挫败。如何正确地处理这种情况,关系到问题的解决,更影响到孩子的道德发展和家长与孩子之间的关系。当孩子做错事不认错时,家长的角色非常关键。通过建 …

    2024-10-23
    291254941
  • 孩子在学校犯错了怎样和班主任沟通

    充分准备、展现尊重和信任、 学会倾听和理解等。孩子在学校的成长过程中难免会犯错,这是他们成长的一部分。当面对这种情况时,家长与老师之间的有效沟通显得尤为重要。探讨如何与孩子的班主任进行有效的沟通,以共 …

    2024-10-23
    9392
  • 丧偶式教育对孩子的影响 “丧偶式育儿”对宝宝影响大

    “丧偶式育儿”对宝宝影响大丧偶式教育对孩子的影响有:让孩子缺乏自信、有很深的亲子隔阂、孩子很难有责任心。丧偶式教育很多是父亲对家庭态度冷漠,他们忙于工作或者是根本不想承担责任,不管自己妻子和孩子的死活 …

    2024-10-23
    761318
  • 少年四大名捕挂机版下载

    少年四大名捕挂机版是一款根据少年四大名捕改编的放置类手游,全新的人物形象,经典的角色扮演手游培养系统,让玩家能够实时体验游戏的乐趣!如果你也想玩的话,赶紧来2265安卓网下载吧!少年四大名捕挂机版游戏 …

    2024-10-23
    346334
  • 孩子假努力的5点明显特征有哪些

    在教育孩子的过程中,家长常常会遇到一种现象——孩子看起来非常努力,却没有实质性的进步。这种看似勤奋的行为,实际上可能是“假努力”。表面积极、忽视基础、避重就轻等是几个可以观察到的明显特征。1.表面积极 …

    2024-10-23
    422562862

发表回复

您的电子邮箱地址不会被公开。必填项已用*标注